Year 9 Science · Unit 3 · Lesson 2
Challenge Worksheet
Learning Goals
Explain it to a Year 7 student
Imagine a Year 7 student asks you: "Why is a perpetual motion machine impossible?" Use the sentence starters below to build a clear explanation using what you know about conservation of energy. You can use real examples from everyday life.
Starter 1: "The basic idea of conservation of energy is…"
Starter 2: "A perpetual motion machine would need to… but this is impossible because…"
Starter 3: "In every real machine, some energy always becomes… This means that over time…"
Starter 4: "A good everyday example that shows why perpetual motion is impossible is…"
1. In 2023, an inventor claimed to have built a machine that produces more electricity than it consumes, a so-called "over-unity" device. Evaluate this claim using the law of conservation of energy. What would you expect to find if you tested this machine carefully?
2. A pendulum swings back and forth. Each swing is slightly lower than the last. Construct a detailed energy argument to explain this observation. In your answer, identify the system, describe all energy transformations, and explain why the pendulum does not violate conservation of energy even as it loses height.
Wrap Up
In one sentence, what was the main idea of this lesson?