Year 8 Science · Unit 2 · Lesson 04
Apply Worksheet
Learning Goals
Predict and reason
Read the scenario, then answer both questions below.
Scenario
A Year 8 student uses a set of coloured balls and sticks to build an atom model for her assessment. Her model shows electrons as small yellow balls attached by sticks in fixed circular rings around a central red ball (the nucleus). She is proud of her model and says it shows exactly what an atom looks like.
(a) Predict one thing her model shows accurately about the structure of an atom.
(b) Predict one way the model is not accurate compared to how electrons actually behave. Justify your answer using what you know about model limitations.
Real-world scenario
Read the context below, then answer the questions using ideas from this lesson.
Real-world context
Google Maps is a model of the real world. It shows roads, buildings and land, but it does not show the exact height of every tree, every pothole, or changes that happened five minutes ago. Despite these limitations, scientists, emergency workers, and field researchers regularly use Google Maps to plan routes and study environments, even though they know the map is not perfectly accurate.
(a) Explain how the way scientists use Google Maps is similar to the way scientists use atomic models like the Bohr model.
(b) What would make Google Maps 'wrong' in the same way that an atomic model can be 'wrong'? Give a specific example in your answer.
1. The Bohr model shows electrons in fixed circular rings. Scientists now know electrons do not move in precise circles. Explain why the Bohr model is still useful for Year 8 science, even though it is not fully accurate.
2. Describe one situation where you would need a more detailed model than the Bohr model. Explain why the Bohr model would not be enough in that situation.
Wrap Up
In one sentence, what was the main idea of this lesson?